Search


 
 

Just What We Need: Slicker Infertility Marketing

Posted by Gina Maranto, Biopolitical Times guest contributor on October 21st, 2016


Untitled Document

The most unsettling line in the recent Forbes article on the ambitious infertility startup Prelude comes about halfway through. “The IVF industry in the United States,” writes Miguel Helft, “has everything private equity likes—scale (about $2 billion annually) and growth (more than 10% a year), along with being fragmented and having outdated marketing.” 

In an era with precious few opportunities for double digit returns, why not turn the reproductive health sector into the next big thing by furthering its consolidation and selling services using lifestyle content?  “Hey,” Prelude’s hipster-chic splash page calls out, “how’s your fertility doing?” 

A woman in a polka dot blouse lounging on a couch looks directly in the camera with the text "Hey, how's your fertility doing?" in bright font.

If that piques your interest, scrolling down takes you on a kind of virtual stroll through the streets of Williamsburg, Wicker Park, or the Mission District, where you encounter edgily coifed, tatted, and bespectacled folk who presumably are spending as much time thinking about their reproductive fitness as they do their next Americano or Kimchi taco.  But you’ll find scant information about financial, psychological, or medical risks of egg retrieval (unless you count the presumed donor pictured alongside the quotation “I was worried about the discomfort, but seriously, it was no worse than a bikini wax—and for a much higher purpose”) or about failure rates after eggs are thawed and implanted.  Everything is upbeat and empowering, geared toward the “millennial mindset of health, wellness, and control.”

Prelude is targeting 20 to 30 year olds and the main product it’s selling them is their own eggs and sperm on ice.  The site proclaims, “If you are in your 20s or early 30s, there is no better time than now to bank your eggs and sperm. They are stretchy and full of reproductive life force, just like you!” (Must be all that hot bikram yoga, huh?) 

A woman with spectables and a backpack in a city street looks into the camera, with the text "Press Pause" in bright font.

With $200 million in funding, Prelude founder, chairman, and CEO Martin Varsavsky, who bills himself as a “serial tech entrepreneur,” laid the foundation of the company by acquiring controlling stakes in one of the largest IVF clinics in the country, Reproductive Biology Associates in Atlanta, which in 2016 had net sales of just over $5 million; and their partner, My Egg Bank, which gives would-be parents access to frozen eggs through a network of infertility clinics.  Already profitable, Prelude also offers a product line for 40-somethings in the form of “screened donor eggs.”  Helft writes that Prelude’s aim is “to take [egg and sperm freezing] mainstream, giving it scale and Silicon Valley pizzazz.” 

It all puts one in mind of nothing so much as the international market in animal sperm and embryos.  Reproductive technology in animals far predates that in humans: British scientist Walter Heape (himself a serial entrepreneur) produced the first successful mammalian embryo transfer in 1890 with rabbits.  By the mid-1960s, animal sperm banks could be found around the world, and one study estimated that the cattle industry had by then performed artificial insemination on 59 million cows, 47 million ewes, 1 million sows, 125,000 mares, 56,000 goats, and 4 million turkeys.  Businesses like Bovine Elite, Cattle Visions, and Cattle Genie are part of a multimillion-dollar global trade in cattle semen and embryos that has all but eliminated traditional mating and led to stacked pedigrees and reduced genetic variability.   (One Wisconsin bull who sired some 500,000 offspring made national headlines when he died.)

While American Society of Reproductive Medicine guidelines currently suggest limiting the use of a single male’s sperm to 25 recipients (there are no suggested limits for donor eggs or embryos), what’s to say we won’t see the human version of cattle breeding as marketing takes precedence and consumer demand drives clinical practice?  History provides ample evidence of the ways in which global capital tends to push enterprises toward greater scale and homogeneity—from fast food to pop culture to higher education.

Fifty years from now, historians could look back and see that Prelude, along with other egg banking and IVF-clinic networks duking it out for international market share, laid the groundwork for branded gametes and embryos, all under the soothing guise of offering customers “insurance” on their reproductive viability. 

Gina Maranto is a fellow at the Center for Genetics and Society. She is Director of Ecosystem Science and Policy and Coordinator of the Environmental Science and Policy program at the University of Miami's Leonard and Jayne Abess Center. Her articles, opinion pieces, and reviews have appeared in Discover,The Atlantic Monthly, Scientific American, The New York Times, and other publications. She is the author of Quest for Perfection: The Drive to Breed Better Human Beings.

 

Previously on Biopolitical Times:

Images via Prelude Fertility and Pixabay





Posted in Assisted Reproduction, Bioethics, Biotech & Pharma, Egg Retrieval, Genetic Selection, Media Coverage, Patents & Other IP, Personal genomics, Reproductive Justice, Health & Rights, US Federal


Comments

Add a Comment
  1. Comment by Michael, Feb 13th, 2017 8:55pm

    Very interesting article. Selling sperm and eggs? Haha


  2. Comment by tutu helper, Jan 24th, 2017 2:33am

    very Thanks to you.


  3. Comment by voot ios, Dec 26th, 2016 12:02pm

    Thanks for the fantastic things you provided in this article.


  4. Comment by Ruby Norman , Dec 26th, 2016 4:33am

    It`s good that modern medicine develops so fast. And many infertile people have an opportunity to have own children. I faced infertility like many of them. My daughter was born with the help of IVF technologies. I use this service in Ukraine. It is one of the countries, where doctors use only fresh biomaterial. In one of the clinics, Biotexcom there`s such a good one. This clinic returns your money is 5 IVF attempts weren`t successful. Surprisingly, from the first try my daughter got pregnant! Her baby is 7 month now. She behaves completely like other women. We had the opportunity to see our granddaughter only when she was a month. Her mother tries to manage with her without our help. And I understand her. He overcame a lot of difficulties and wants to be sure that the baby will be okay.


  5. Comment by Ruby Norman , Dec 26th, 2016 4:33am

    It`s good that modern medicine develops so fast. And many infertile people have an opportunity to have own children. I faced infertility like many of them. My daughter was born with the help of IVF technologies. I use this service in Ukraine. It is one of the countries, where doctors use only fresh biomaterial. In one of the clinics, Biotexcom there`s such a good one. This clinic returns your money is 5 IVF attempts weren`t successful. Surprisingly, from the first try my daughter got pregnant! Her baby is 7 month now. She behaves completely like other women. We had the opportunity to see our granddaughter only when she was a month. Her mother tries to manage with her without our help. And I understand her. He overcame a lot of difficulties and wants to be sure that the baby will be okay.


  6. Comment by iOS Geekers, Nov 24th, 2016 10:20am

    I like the template of your blog. Could you tell name of your template through my mail ? Thanks in advance.


  7. Comment by Add Comment, Nov 10th, 2016 11:09pm

    Our lawyers and administrative staff work together as a cohesive team to provide exceptional service to our clients. We are always on the lookout for talented people. Are you a candidate for the Torkin Manes team?

    Add Comment


  8. Comment by Add Comment, Nov 10th, 2016 11:07pm

    Our lawyers and administrative staff work together as a cohesive team to provide exceptional service to our clients. We are always on the lookout for talented people. Are you a candidate for the Torkin Manes team?

    Add Comment


  9. Comment by suicide squad harley quinn jacket at amazon, Nov 7th, 2016 5:27am

    Effectual marketing topic! Itís an updated marketing content as a recent observation. Thanx much


  10. Comment by BB Rec App, Oct 27th, 2016 8:04am

    Really this is very useful and every one should know about it.It is better If you are in your 20s or early 30s, there is no better time than now to bank your eggs and sperm.I appreciate your work for providing this info. BB Rec is the latest screen recorder for ios to record your home screen activities.


  11. Comment by BB Rec App, Oct 27th, 2016 8:03am

    Really this is very useful and every one should know about it.It is better If you are in your 20s or early 30s, there is no better time than now to bank your eggs and sperm.I appreciate your work for providing this info. BB Rec is the latest screen recorder for ios to record your home screen activities.


 


ESPAÑOL | PORTUGUÊS | Русский

home | overview | blog | publications | about us | donate | newsletter | press room | privacy policy

CGS • 1120 University Ave, Suite 100, Berkeley, CA 94702 USA • • (p) 1.510.625.0819 • (F) 1.510.665.8760